Back to learning exercises hit list
Search all MERLOT
Click here to go to your profile
Select to go to your workspace
Click here to go to your Dashboard Report
Click here to go to your Content Builder
Click here to log out
Search Terms
Enter username
Enter password
Please give at least one keyword of at least three characters for the search to work with. The more keywords you give, the better the search will work for you.
select OK to launch help window
cancel help

MERLOT II


    

Learning Exercise


Material: Calibrated Peer Review
Submitted by: Nancy J. Pelaez on Jul 09, 2000
Date Last Modified: Jul 09, 2000
Title: Bioethics and Current Issues
Description: Students model an exploration, collaborative discussions, and then assessment via asynchronous internet delivery to delve into on-line resources about ethics and issues in biology.
Type of Task: Core activity, Individual, Student-centered, Supplemental activity, Team, Unsupervised
Time Required 1 week outside of class time.
Topics: Bioethics
Asynchronous learning.
Discussion.
Course: SCED 504 Advanced Technology in Science Learning Environments
Audience: Professional
Categories:
Prerequisites Skills: Basic web browser and navigation skills.
Graduate standing with an undergraduate science major.
Learning Objectives: To be able to identify and and justify the most socially and morally acceptable compromise for an issue using the ABCDE method of ethical decision-making that involves Argument, considering Both sides, Costs and benefits, making a Decision, and then Evaluating that decision.
Technical Notes: Students need access to a bulletin board, for example, via Blackboard or Web CT. The text submitted should then be formatted with some basc html flags. The lesson shows a preview of the CPR assignment, but the version that students view on-line through calibrated peer review looks better becuase it uses java script.
Text of Learning Exercise:



6. Bioethics - done
















Assignment
Preview

 




Title: 6. Bioethics and Current Issues


Assignment
Goals


Source
Material


Writing
Prompt





Hit Counter
                                                          
Please
COMMENT










Assignment
Goals


You will use the electronic bulletin board for this assignment to select one ethical issue to discuss. The goal is to be able to identify and and justify the most socially and morally acceptable compromise for this issue. You will try out the ABCDE method of ethical decision-making that involves Argument, considering Both sides, Costs and benefits, making a Decision, and then Evaluating that decision.


Carol K. Johnansen and David E. Harris, Teaching the Ethics of Biology, The American Biology Teacher 62: 356-357, May, 2000.






Top








Source
Material


Use the bulletin board to share idea as you explore the resources until you come to group consensus about which one
ethical issue the group would like to address. Then discuss the ABCDE's of that issue.
Please e-mail your instructor if you find links that should be added to these ethics resources. (npelaez@fullerton.edu)




Top







cellpadding="2">


















Source Material Resources:

Brain Bank donations

- Why should people donate their brains to research when they die? Why don't they? Thanks to Dr. Brian J. Cummings of the Tissue Repository, Institute for Brain Aging at U.C. Irvine for suggesting these web sites.


URL: http://www.alz.uci.edu/repository.html

Conceiving a Clone

- Should we allow human beings to be cloned?


URL: http://library.thinkquest.org/24355/home.html

Gene testing

- Should we get ourselves tested for defective genes?


URL: http://rex.nci.nih.gov/PATIENTS/INFO_TEACHER/Gene_testing/Title.html

Genes and Society

- This links to a host of resources that deal with ethical issues.


URL: http://www.dnafiles.org/resources/res07.html





















The
Scientist
-
Register for your free on-line subscription to the Scientist. Then look for the
Opinion article BREAKING DOWN CANCER on page 39 of the February 21,
2000 issue, OR use the search engine for a list of articles that
address ethics.

URL: http://www.the-scientist.com/memberlogin.htm
ASSIGNMENT:
the ABCD Method
 

URL: http://faculty.fullerton.edu/npelaez/SCED504/6Bioethics/ABCDEthics.htm
Introduction
to public health ethics


URL: http://www.cdc.gov/epo/surveillancein/lesson102.htm
Equity
in math and science education
-
This is a mailing list archive with several articles of
interest.

URL: http://nici-mc2.org/mailing/ra-equity/mail/maillist.html
Federal
Pollution locator
 

URL: http://www.scorecard.org/env-releases/land/

cellpadding="2">








Top







Writing
Prompt


Given all the arguments, costs and benefits and final decision that developed through the bulletin board discussion on the one ethical issue selected, write a summary. Describe and justify the most socially and morally acceptable compromise. Consider each item in the ABCDE method of ethical decision-making according to Carol K. Johnansen and David E. Harris, Teaching the Ethics of Biology, The American Biology Teacher 62: 356-357, May, 2000.








Top






Dr. Nancy J. Pelaez

MaSTERS, College of Natural Sciences and Mathematics

California State University, Fullerton

Copyright ? 2000.  All rights reserved.

Revised: June 30, 2000
.





Additional Information URL: http://cpr.molsci.ucla.edu:8800/cpr_info/
Bookmark and Share