Back to comment hit list
Back to comment hit list

MERLOT II


    

Comment


Material:

Story of Stuff Project with Annie Leonard

Rating: 1 star
Used in Course: Not used in course
Submitted by: Rick Weber (Faculty), Jul 09, 2012
Comment:

On its own this video is absolute garbage. Anyone with a modest grasp of economics will cringe at Leonard's unsatisfactory analysis.

Pros: Great production value, compelling presentation, and well known outside economics department (i.e. allows students to reach outside of their discipline while on campus).

Cons: Overrun with economic fallacies and poor analysis.

Recommended use: This video could be used to teach students about rhetoric, and how to write about economic issues. Debunking this video provides almost endless possibilities for student op-eds. I wouldn't recommend using this in a principles class, but in an upper division class with a talented lecturer, it could be torn apart in class.