A lesson on whale evolution based on DNA, geological, paleontological, physiological and morphological evidence. Students will experience the historical discovery of fossils which increasingly link whales to earlier land-dwelling mammals. This experience reveals how scientists can make predictions about past events, based on the theory and evidence that whales evolved. Such predictions suggest the age and location of sediments where fossils of early whales would most likely be found, and even their traits. This lesson also provides confirmation, with multiple independent lines of evidence, that there IS a series of intermediate forms, showing gradual accumulation of changes, linking certain terrestrial mammal groups with modern whales.
Type of Material:
Case Study
Recommended Uses:
Individuals might use it as a case study and faculty might use it as an assignment. Elements of this lesson (such as the PowerPoint presentation) may be used by faculty separately.
Technical Requirements:
Web Browser. PowerPoint. Adobe Reader. Word.
Identify Major Learning Goals:
1. Students will recognize the elements of the process of science as reflected in this lesson.2. Students will recognize the role of predictions in science, and how this helped clarify whale evolution.3. Students will explain the evidence leading to a possible revision in the likely ancestors of whales4. Students will give examples of the mosaic nature of evolution in whales.5. Students will identify which whale-like traits appeared earliest, and which ones appeared later.6. Students will explain how the tectonic movement of India into Asia caused changes in the Tethys Sea, and how those changes may have contributed to the emergence of whales.
Target Student Population:
High School, College General Ed
Prerequisite Knowledge or Skills:
Some basic biology, especially evolution and paleontology.
Content Quality
Rating:
Strengths:
The content is good quality and accurate
A variety of content from several disciplines is included
References are provided
The information is a comprehensive survey of what may be studied for this topic
Some rare or hard-to-find images and videos are provided
Concerns:
The material mostly dates from 2008 with some amendment in 2016; it is thus not up to date
The level of content is somewhat uneven--some elements appropriate for high school while other more appropriate for college
Potential Effectiveness as a Teaching Tool
Rating:
Strengths:
For faculty this case study presents a variety of useful elements including assessable objectives; teaching resources such as images, handouts, PowerPoint slides; estimates of lesson time; teaching strategies and preparation; descriptions of the procedure; assessments; and variations and extensions
The specifics of whale evolution are used to illustrate bigger concepts in the nature of science
Information provided helps instructors and students understand the relatedness of the topics
Concerns:
The website is no longer active and exists only on the WayBack machine archive
Some links no longer work and direct to the Indiana University website; The ENSI (evolution and the nature of science) webpages direct users to the WayBack machine for the lesson, so the site is clearly not going to be updated
Some resources are outdated, such as overhead slides, but might be adapted to current technology
Ease of Use for Both Students and Faculty
Rating:
Strengths:
Most links to documents seemed to work
The material is all on one page
The information is organized and follows a logical order
Navigation is intuitive and back buttons all bring the user back to the link they clicked
Concerns:
The website has a very old and not very efficient or user-friendly
Links all seemed to lead to archived materials (on the WayBack Machine) so links to YouTube videos and similar resources no longer work
Other Issues and Comments:
The website is no longer updated and exists in archived form only. A number of significant developments have occurred in our understanding of whale evolution since this site was last updated, hence the low review score. The material is excellent for its time and some may still be useful to instructors.
Creative Commons:
Search by ISBN?
It looks like you have entered an ISBN number. Would you like to search using what you have
entered as an ISBN number?
Searching for Members?
You entered an email address. Would you like to search for members? Click Yes to continue. If no, materials will be displayed first. You can refine your search with the options on the left of the results page.
Searching for Members?
You entered an email address. Would you like to search for members? Click Yes to continue. If no, materials will be displayed first. You can refine your search with the options on the left of the results page.