MERLOT - Multimedia Education Resource for Learning and Online Teaching
Home Communities Learning Materials Member Directory My Profile About Us

Peer Review

Become a Member | Log In

Evolution Website

 

Ratings

Overall Rating:

4 stars
Content Quality: 4 stars
Effectiveness: 4 stars
Ease of Use: 4 stars
Reviewed: Apr 24, 2002 by Biology Editorial Board
Overview:

This BBC Education site contains a wide variety of material and, while it is not intended as a lecture, contains a great deal of educationally relevant material. It is an excellent resource for students and instructors seeking in depth information on Darwin and evolution. The site has seven distinct sections, each of which may be applicable depending on the instructor’s objectives.



  1. The Origin Online: This section has the entire text of The Origin of Species with an illustrated guide and a good annotated bibliography with active links to other sites. The Origin of Species is available chapter by chapter online or may be downloaded in its entirety.

  2. Darwin: The Man and His Legacy: This section contains a biography of Charles Darwin, a History of Darwinism, A Christian Response To Darwinian Theories of Evolution, Darwin and Darwinism (a discussion of Darwin’s theories, how they arose, and impacts of later findings by Richard Dawkins), and Darwin, Genes, and Determinism (a critique of “fundamentalist”
    Darwinism.)

  3. Alife: This is an artificial life game that demonstrates survival
    and extinction in a population. It is a Java program with instructions and
    ability to design new organisms. The section also includes links to other
    artificial life and artificial intelligence (AI) sites.

  4. Transcripts of the Life On Earth television series: Complete transcripts
    are available; probably not very useful for educational purposes.

  5. The Extinction Files: This section is a series of short articles
    on mass extinction, theories of extinction, patterns in extinction events,
    biodiversity today, and links to other sites on extinction.

  6. Fossil Roadshow: This section contains a series of articles on fossils
    and fossil collecting. The article on amber is particularly good.

  7. Natural Selections: This section is a set of RealVideo files that
    are interviews with naturalists and biologists about evolution and what organisms
    particularly interest them and why. Included are such persons as Douglas Adams,
    Jane Goodall, Richard Dawkins, and David Attenborough.


Instructors will need to review each section and determine what part(s) are
most applicable to their course. The site contains a wealth of information for
instructors and students. High school students and undergraduates doing research
on Darwin and the beginnings of our modern understanding of evolution will be
able to mine a great deal of information from this site.

Target Student Population: High school students and undergraduates doing research on Darwin and the
beginnings of our modern understanding of evolution
Type of Material: HTML with sound and video files
Technical Requirements: RealPlayer with video and sound card for the Natural Selections pages. Java for Alife.

Evaluation and Observation

Content Quality

Rating: 4 stars
Strengths:

Quality of Content: (4) (3) = 3.5



  • Personal comments by recognized authorities in biology provide insight on
    how scientists are motivated and think about their field.

  • Wide coverage of history and concepts of evolution by authoritative
    persons.

Concerns:

Potential Effectiveness as a Teaching Tool

Rating: 4 stars
Strengths:

Potential Effectiveness: (4) (4) = 4



  • Annotated links to other relevant sites.

  • Provides access to original source documents.

  • Alife game and links to other artificial life games could be used for
    interactive
    exercises.

Concerns:

  • A series of exercises keyed to the different sections of this site to
    guide
    students to relevant concepts/facts/issues would increase the effectiveness
    of the site for education.



Ease of Use for Both Students and Faculty

Rating: 4 stars
Strengths:

Usability: (4) (4) = 4



  • Well written text material.

Concerns:

  • Simulation (Alife) is abstract and requires careful review of the
    instructions
    to make it work.


Other Issues and Comments:

Overall Rating: (4) (3.67) = 3.84

--%>