MERLOT - Multimedia Education Resource for Learning and Online Teaching
Home Communities Learning Materials Member Directory My Profile About Us

Peer Review

Become a Member | Log In

Harvest of Fear

by
 

Ratings

Overall Rating:

4 stars
Content Quality: 4 stars
Effectiveness: 5 stars
Ease of Use: 5 stars
Reviewed: Jun 25, 2002 by Biology Editorial Board
Overview: Harvest of Fear is a web site dealing with the topic of genetically modified
(transgenic) crops. The site is subdivided into four parts. Part one is titled
?Should we grow GM crops?? and discuses relevant health, environmental and
financial issues. At the end of this part, students may vote whether they
support the use of such technology and will see the current results of the
voting survey. Part two, titled ?Engineer a crop? is the showcase of the site
and includes two interactive activities, one a selective breeding simulation for
selecting corn plants with large ear size, the other to make transgenic
manipulations creating a tomato plant resistant to certain insects by
incorporating a gene from a bacterium that produces toxins harmful to insects
but not mammals. Part three is titled ?Guess what?s coming to dinner? and
discusses information about the next wave of GM foods that are in development.
Part four ?Viewpoints? is the least useful of the sections and is a collection
of view points.
Learning Goals: Simulate the steps used to create a transgenic crop. Identify some of the
current and future uses of transgenic crops as well as identify valid concerns
of this technology.
Target Student Population: Advanced high school through college level.
Prerequisite Knowledge or Skills: A general knowledge of genetics and the basic principles of recombinant DNA
technology.
Type of Material: Interactive simulation.
Recommended Uses: An interactive tutorial showing the steps used to create a transgenic crop. The
simulation could be used to teach the basics of this technique, or could be
used prior to an actual laboratory activity in which transgenic plants are
created.
Technical Requirements: Shockwave and Flash plugins

Evaluation and Observation

Content Quality

Rating: 4 stars
Strengths: Quality of content: (4.0 , 4.25 ) = 4.1

Features of excellence:


  • Good representation of factual information on a complicated topic
  • Very balanced point of view presented on a potentially controversial
    issue
  • Interactive graphics for the creation of the transgenic tomato plant well
    thought out and clear
  • Useful links to other web sites


Concerns: None

Potential Effectiveness as a Teaching Tool

Rating: 5 stars
Strengths: Potential effectiveness as a teaching tool: (4.5 , 4.5 ) = 4.5

Features of excellence:


  • Information on the web site stands alone for teaching the topic of
    transgenic
    organisms?site could substitute for classroom instruction
  • Simulation of creating a transgenic crop is detailed enough to allow
    interesting exam or quiz questions regarding the technology used
  • Information presented in an understandable manner so that non-science majors

    could benefit substantially from this site.


Concerns: None

Ease of Use for Both Students and Faculty

Rating: 5 stars
Strengths: Usability: (4.5 , 4.5) = 4.5

Features of excellence:


  • Clear and accurate directions in the simulation
  • Site easy to navigate
  • No defective links


Concerns: None

Other Issues and Comments: Overall ranking: 4.4
--%>