- Home
- Peer Review: Multilingual Making in a Second-Language Poetry Club | CERCLL
Peer Review
Multilingual Making in a Second-Language Poetry Club | CERCLL
- Reviewed:
Feb 14, 2025 by Teacher Education
Ratings
- Overview:
This OER is a culmination of conversations, pedagogical practices, and ways of being together that developed as a collaboration between co-authors Borbala Gaspar and Chantelle Warner (at the University of Arizona) and the engaged group of students who took part in a year-long series of extracurricular gatherings, which served as an exploratory space for the ideas shared in this handbook.
The poetry club evolved from the authors’ shared desire to create a space adjacent to the classrooms in their language programs (Italian and German respectively) where students could explore the aesthetic and affective endeavor of language learning, rooted in the human capacity for exploring alternative ways of making sense of themselves, the world, and their experiences within it.
This handbook is intended as a resource for educators who wish to develop a similar extracurricular club or who are looking for inspiration for their classrooms. In the first chapter of the handbook, we introduce you to the background of the project and the current discussions of well-being in higher education.
Part two provides an overview of the conceptual underpinnings of multilingual making and poetic play as ways of engaging with language and language learning.
Core concepts and principles are outlined, emphasizing the significance of living together in and through languages, and the role of multilingual making when learning a new language.
The handbook explores various forms of poetic play, such as collage, response artwork to poetry, clay work and visual representation of poems. It delves into core principles for establishing a multilingual poetry club offering guidance on creating and sustaining such a club.
Sample activities illustrate each example including collage, mixed media, limericks, and remarks from the authors and creators of the artworks. Additional resources such as blackout poetry and other ideas that could potentially further engage club members in creative expression are included as well.
Finally, this book concludes with reflections and additional resources for educators interested in promoting multilingualism and creativity through poetry.
- Type of Material:
Tutorial/Guide/Handbook with samples
- Recommended Uses:
"Multilingual Making in a Second-Language Poetry Club" is a versatile resource that can be utilized in various educational settings to enhance language learning through creative expression.
The book serves as a didactic, practical guide for educators to create a yearlong series of exploratory gatherings, which the authors offered as a set of collaborative-optional, open-ended, self-paced, extracurricular activities.
Here are some recommended uses:
1. Extracurricular Poetry Club:
The handbook is specifically designed to guide educators in establishing extracurricular poetry clubs that promote multilingualism. These clubs can provide a relaxed environment where students collaboratively explore and create poetry across different languages, fostering a sense of community and belonging.
2. In-Class Activities:
Educators can integrate the sample activities from the handbook into their regular language classes. For instance, activities like collage creation, response artwork, and visual representation of poems can be conducted in small groups to encourage teamwork and deepen engagement with the language material.
3. Workshops and Seminars:
The concepts and activities outlined can be adapted for workshops or seminars focused on creative language learning techniques. These sessions can be beneficial for both students and educators interested in innovative approaches to language acquisition.
4. Self-Paced Learning:
Individuals interested in exploring multilingual poetry can use the handbook as a self-study guide. The detailed explanations and examples allow learners to engage with the material at their own pace, experimenting with different forms of poetic expression.
5. Professional Development for Educators:
Language instructors can utilize this resource for professional development, gaining insights into incorporating creative, multilingual activities into their teaching practices. The handbook offers theoretical foundations alongside practical applications, making it a valuable tool for educators aiming to enrich their methodology.
By leveraging the diverse applications of this handbook, educators and learners can enrich the language learning experience, making it more engaging and inclusive.
- Technical Requirements:
A PDF reader to access this web browser-enbedded PDF.
- Identify Major Learning Goals:
After reading this book, the educator will be able to:
- Identify key factors students indicate that influence their senseof belonging.
- Define key concepts and terms related to playful poetry and living literacies approach.
- Relate the playful poetry and living literacies approaches to other discussions in the field of second-language teaching and learning.
- Explore the forms and functions of multimodality and living literacies through the provided samples.
- Reflect on how you want to apply the ideas about poetic play and living literacies into various disciplines in K-12 and higher education contexts without the learner having prerequisite knowledge of either discipline.
- Target Student Population:
Elementary School, Middle School, High School, College General Ed, College Lower Division, College Upper Division, Graduate School
- Prerequisite Knowledge or Skills:
Aside from critical thinking (to apply the concepts to disciplines other linguistics or those that facilitate language learning), no prerequisite knowledge or skills needed.
Content Quality
- Rating:
-
- Strengths:
"Multilingual Making in a Second-Language Poetry Club" is an open educational resource (OER) developed by Borbala Gaspar and Chantelle Warner at the University of Arizona. This handbook serves as a comprehensive guide for educators interested in establishing extracurricular poetry clubs that foster multilingualism and creative expression among language learners
The handbook is structured to provide both theoretical insights and practical applications.
- It begins with an introduction to the project's background, emphasizing the importance of well-being in higher education.
- Subsequent sections delve into the concepts of multilingual making and poetic play, highlighting their roles in language engagement and learning.
- The authors offer detailed guidance on various forms of poetic activities, including collage, response artwork, clay work, and visual representations of poems.
- Each activity is accompanied by sample projects and reflections from both educators and students, providing a rich resource for implementation.
The book references seminal and contemporary literature to describe the concepts and skills needed to promote multilingualism and creativity through poetry. Although the authors specifically state the design is not intended to enhance language learning, the model they present is useful, as it fosters belonging and appreciation for the arts. Since thorough information is provided in the samples, no prerequisite knowledge or advanced learning is needed for any discipline, other than the domain the educator chooses to pair with poetry.
- Concerns:
There are no concerns regarding concent quality.
Potential Effectiveness as a Teaching Tool
- Rating:
-
- Strengths:
With this resource, the educator is the student. The resource meets the educator at the engage phase of the learning cycle. Once the concepts are understood (and encapsulated upon after reviewing the sample projects), educators can quickly move through the explain, elaborate, and evaluate phases of the learning cycle by critically thinking about how to apply the provided model into their discipline.
- This resource is designed to enhance language learning by integrating creative practices that promote a sense of belonging and community among participants. By engaging in multilingual poetic activities, students can explore and express their identities, experiences, and emotions in a supportive environment.
- The handbook outlines clear objectives, such as helping educators identify factors influencing students' sense of belonging and applying the concepts of playful poetry and living literacies in their teaching contexts.
- The inclusion of multimodal activities caters to diverse learning styles, potentially increasing student motivation and retention.
- Concerns:
Although touted as an extracurricular opportunity for belonging and engagement, the resource does not promote language development. If used in a classroom setting, an educator might prefer to maximize the effectiveness of this model.
With additional study on arts integration, this model can be used to teach both the core principles of poetry and the educator's discipline. In that instance, applicable learning goals can be drafted with slightly modified assignments to help the student reach the learning goals. If arts engagement is the overarching objective, the concepts promoted in this book serves as an exemplary model of using the arts in a multimodal way to engage students with another discipline.
Ease of Use for Both Students and Faculty
- Rating:
-
- Strengths:
From an accessiblity standpoint, PDF resource promotes ease of use with a clean, clear design, appropriately sized graphics and images that can be read by a screenreader, and tagged content--the latter of which is evidenced by its tag tree in the document outline.
- The handbook is well-organized, with each section building upon the previous one to provide a cohesive understanding of establishing and sustaining a multilingual poetry club.
- The language is accessible, making it suitable for educators with varying levels of experience in creative language teaching methodologies.
- Practical examples and additional resources, such as blackout poetry ideas, are provided to inspire and assist educators in implementing the activities.
- The resource is freely available online under a Creative Commons CC BY-NC license, allowing educators to adapt and share the material for noncommercial purposes with proper attribution.
- Concerns:
None