This study explores learners' critical thinking practices about their mathematics learning process, focusing on how their beliefs reveal capacities to reflect and suggest improvements. This research addresses a gap in mathematics education literature that has predominantly examined critical thinking in cognitive domains (problem-solving) and socio-political contexts, while the personal aspectparticularly learners' beliefs about their own learning processes-has received limited attention. The study employed a qualitative approach with data collected through questionnaires and semi-structured interviews from 74 eighth and ninth-grade learners across two schools in Indonesia. Data analysis utilized the critical thinking skills framework, specifically the self-examination and self-correction subskills of the self-regulation dimension (Facione, 1990). Questionnaire results revealed significant inconsistencies in learners' beliefs: 32% (24 out of 74) held contradictory views between liking mathematics and considering it important for careers; 31% (23 out of 74) showed inconsistency between liking mathematics and considering it important for further studies; and 28% (21 out of 74) stated they liked mathematics yet considered what they learned a waste of time, or vice versa. Interview analysis from 20 learners demonstrated difficulties in self-examination-only 8 out of 20 could identify unhelpful mathematics topics, and 17 out of 20 could only mention basic mathematics applications (shopping, cooking) without connecting advanced mathematics to real-life contexts. Fifteen out of 20 learners were unaccustomed to questioning their beliefs, frequently responding with "I don't know" and demonstrating uncritical acceptance of the curriculum. However, the research also revealed hidden potential: when given time and encouragement, 15 out of 20 learners could provide improvement suggestions, including one learner who designed a comprehensive lesson plan about family budgeting. This indicates that although critical thinking practices about mathematics learning remain underdeveloped, learners possess the capacity for critical thinking when appropriately facilitated. The study concludes that belief inconsistencies among learners closely relate to insufficient practice in critical thinking about their own learning processes. Learners are unaccustomed to examining and correcting their beliefs, hindering the development of meta-perspectives on mathematics learning. Recommendations include explicit training in critical thinking about mathematics learning in classrooms, particularly given that 13-14-year-old learners will soon face important educational transitions (after grade 10) requiring reflective decision-making about their mathematics education.
Torang Siregar (Researcher)